Americans In Civil War Essay, Research Paper
The foundation for black participation in the Civil War began more than a
hundred years before the outbreak of the war. Blacks in America had been in
bondage since early colonial times. In 1776, when Jefferson proclaimed
mankind?s inalienable right to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness,
the institution of slavery had become firmly established in America. Blacks
worked in the tobacco fields of Virginia, in the rice fields of South Carolina,
and toiled in small farms and shops in the North. Foner and Mahoney report in A
House Divided, America in the Age of Lincoln that, ?In 1776, slaves composed
forty percent of the population of the colonies from Maryland south to Georgia,
but well below ten percent in the colonies to the North.? The invention of the
cotton gin by Eli Whitney in 1793 provided a demand for cotton thus increasing
the demand for slaves. By the 1800?s slavery was an institution throughout the
South, an institution in which slaves had few rights, and could be sold or
leased by their owners. They lacked any voice in the government and lived a life
of hardship. Considering these circumstances, the slave population never
abandoned the desire for freedom or the determination to resist control by the
slave owners. The slave’s reaction to this desire and determination resulted in
outright rebellion and individual acts of defiance. However, historians place
the strongest reaction in the enlisting of blacks in the war itself. Batty in
The Divided Union: The Story of the Great American War, 1861-65, concur with
Foner and Mahoney about the importance of outright rebellion in their analysis
of the Nat Turner Rebellion, which took place in 1831. This revolt demonstrated
that not all slaves were willing to accept this ?institution of slavery?
passively. Foner and Mahoney note that the significance of this uprising is
found in its aftermath because of the numerous reports of ?insubordinate?
behavior by slaves. 8 Individual acts of defiance ranged from the use of the
Underground Railroad – a secret, organized network of people who helped fugitive
slaves reach the Northern states and Canada – to the daily resistance or silent
sabotage found on the plantations. Stokesbury acknowledges in, A Short History
of the Civil War, the existence of the Underground Railroad but disagrees with
other historians as to its importance. He notes that it never became as well
organized or as successful as the South believed. Even with the groundwork
having been laid for resistance, the prevalent racial climate in America in 1860
found it unthinkable that blacks would bear arms against white Americans.
However, by 1865 these black soldiers had proven their value. Wilson writes in
great detail describing the struggles and achievements of the black soldiers in
his book The Black Phalanx. McPherson discusses in The Negro?s Civil War that
widespread opposition to the use of blacks as soldiers prevailed among northern
whites. Whereas McPherson relates the events cumulating in the passage of two
laws that aided black enlistment, Wilson focuses on the actual enlistment. He
notes that the first regiment of free blacks came into service at New Orleans in
September 1862 through the efforts of Butler. Wilson credits Butler?s three
regiments of blacks as the first officially mustered into Union ranks. North
Carolina and Kansas also organized additional black units where minor skirmishes
proved to be successful. Wilson also notes that ?Kansas has … the honor of
being the first State in the Union to begin the organization of Negroes as
soldiers for the Federal army.? McPherson believes that up to this point
President Lincoln had opposed the idea of blacks fighting for the Union but
after the issuance of the Emancipation Proclamation, which declared that slaves
in states still in rebellion on January 1, 1863, ?shall be then, thence
forward, and forever free,? he reversed his 8 thinking. At the end of the
Emancipation Proclamation Lincoln announced that the freed blacks ?would be
received into the armed service of the United States….? Lincoln planned to
tap into a new source of fighting individuals, ?…the great available and as
yet unavailed of, force for the restoration of the Union.?. Lincoln thought
this would both weaken the enemy and strengthen the Union. The recruitment of
the blacks took laborers from the South and placed "these men in the Union
army in places which otherwise must be filled with so many white men.? Lincoln
also felt that seeing the blacks fighting against the Confederacy would have a
psychological effect upon the South. With the Emancipation Proclamation of
January 1, 1863, freeing the slaves, the North began recruiting black soldiers
but, as reported by Batty and Parish, this was a slow recruitment at first. In
the Spring of 1863 only two black regiments existed, however, this had grown to
sixty by the end of 1863. By 1864 this had expanded to 80 more regiments. Jordan
provides a comprehensive account of one of the first black regiments to fight
for the Union Army, the 54th Massachusetts Colored Regiment that numbered at
least 1,000 soldiers. This all-volunteer regiment, lead by a white colonel,
Robert Gould Shaw, helped open the 22- month land and sea assault on Charleston,
South Carolina. Leading an unsuccessful hand-to-hand attack on Fort Wagner in
Charleston, this regiment engaged in one of the most famous black actions of the
Civil War and suffered approximately 44 percent casualties, including Colonel
Shaw. Their performance in this battle helped to make the blacks more acceptable
in the Union army. One of its soldiers won the Congressional Medal of Honor.
Eventually twenty-three other black soldiers earned this honor. The reports of
the tenacity of the blacks at Fort Wagner plus 8 engagements at Port Hudson,
Louisiana, Fort Pillow and Milliken?s Bend helped to fuel the fire of black
enlistment. Historians differ in the actual number of blacks in the Union Army.
Foner and Mahoney reported that by the end of the war approximately 190,000
blacks had served in the Union Army and Navy, while Stokesbury notes that there
were 300,000 black soldiers and 166 regiments. McPherson, in contrast, places
this number more than 200,000. Wilson explains the discrepancy in the numbers of
black soldiers as he describes a practice of ?putting a live Negro in a dead
one?s place.? If a black solder died in the war the commanding officers
would simply put another man in his place and have him answer to the dead
man?s name. Batty and Parish call the raising of the black regiments one of
the ?most remarkable, even revolutionary, developments of the whole war.?
Batty and Parish, McPherson and Wilson all agree that even though these soldiers
were fighting for the North and trying to escape the bonds of slavery and gain
freedom, discrimination still existed in the Army. The soldiers fought in
segregated companies with white commanders. The Blacks were not equal to the
whites as they received lower pay, performed fatigue duty and menial labor, such
as cleaning quarters, laundering clothing, cleaning boots and cooking. Black
soldiers, regardless of their rank, earned $10 a month minus $3 for clothing,
while white privates earned $13 a month plus clothing. Ex-slaves could not
advance into the ranks of commissioned officers until the end of the war. Batty
and Parish note that less than 100 ever became officers and none ranked higher
than captain. McPherson, who agrees with other historians that the blacks were
considered second class soldiers, cites statistics to support this theory. He
shows the contrast in the number of white and black soldiers killed in action
and in the rate of death from disease 8 among the white and black soldiers. The
black soldiers faced the prospect of execution or sale into slavery if captured.
Wilson reports that one of the worst atrocities allegedly committed against the
black soldiers occurred at Fort Pillow, Tennessee on April 12, 1864, when the
Confederate Army indiscriminately killed some three hundred black soldiers. The
fort, stormed by General Nathan Bedford Forrest?s troops, had surrendered.
Union officials claimed that the killing of the black soldiers was a massacre,
however, the Confederate denied this claim, maintaining that the soldiers died
in the fighting before the surrender. Wilson gives a detailed account of the
battle to support the massacre theory and Harper?s Weekly called the battle,
?Inhuman, fiendish butchery.? Stokesbury, in concurring with Wilson, notes
?the weight of evidence … suggests a massacre.? This massacre failed to
weaken the courage of the black soldiers, but rather fueled them with a desire
of determination. Just as the Union Army realized the importance of black
soldiers, so did the South. The readiness to which these slaves responded to the
call of fighting for the confederacy is explained by the fact that the failure
of Nat Turner, among others, was held up to them as their fate, should they
attempt to free themselves from their masters. In the early years of the war
some Confederate states accepted blacks into their units, much to Jefferson
Davis?s opposition. Black workers found their way into armament factories and
into the Confederate Army doing anything short of handling a gun. Throughout the
war effort in the South, blacks willingly dug field fortifications, mounted
cannons and built entrenchments to fortify cities and towns. Wilson cites an
article in the Charleston Mercury on January 3, 1861, which reported, ?One
hundred and fifty able-bodied free colored men yesterday offered their services
gratuitously…. to hasten forward the important work of throwing up
redoubts…along our coast.? Likewise, the states of 8 Tennessee and Virginia
enlisted the aid of the blacks. Often after completing the needed fortifications
the slaves returned to the fields to help supply the needs of the confederate
soldiers who were fighting to keep the blacks as slaves. As the Confederacy
faced a mounting shortage of white soldiers, General Pat Cleburne developed a
plan to use the blacks in the fight for the Confederacy. This plan promised
freedom for the slaves but Jefferson Davis rejected the idea. In the dying days
of the war in early 1865 the Confederacy faced an army that was daily thinned
more to desertion than bullets. General-in chief of the Confederate Army General
Robert E. Lee persuaded the Confederate Congress to arm slaves to fight for the
South. These slaves trained, drilled and paraded in some cities. However, the
war ended before this program could begin. Their importance in the fighting is
found in the claim they staked to equal rights following the war. Former slave
Frederick Douglas wrote, ?Once let the black man get upon his person the brass
U. S. … and there is no power on earth which can deny that he has earned the
right to citizenship.? . The role of the black soldiers also influenced
moderate Republicans to believe that the federal government should guarantee the
equality before the law of all citizens. Small, but significant, steps developed
following the war towards easing the color line. For example, street cars became
desegregated in several major cities. Illinois, which in 1862 had banned blacks
from coming into the state, now lifted the ban, and allowed blacks to serve on
juries and to testify in courts. Whereas other historians confine their accounts
of black involvement in the Civil War, Catton notes in The Civil War that as a
result of their fighting along side white soldiers a new attitude developed
towards the blacks. Many northern soldiers had grown up knowing only the black
as portrayed on the stage – grinning, big-mouthed, carefree 8 loving possum and
watermelons and eating fried chicken. What they found was a real human -
struggling to be in control of his destiny. He describes a Wisconsin soldier?s
feelings by saying, ?The black folks are awful good, poor miserable things
that they are. The boys talk to them fearful and treat them most any way and yet
they can?t talk two minutes but tears come to their eyes and they throw their
arms up and praise de Lord for de coming of de Lincoln soldiers.? Deeply
entrenched in the institution of slavery, the black population responded by
playing an important role in the Civil War. This role began years before the
actual fighting, with the foundation being laid by outright rebellion and
individual resistance as the slaves dreamed of freedom. Building on this
foundation historians agree that the role of the blacks in the fighting of the
Civil War was important to both the North and South efforts. Consequently, the
historians agree agreement that one important result of their fighting was the
advancement of the idea of their freedom and steps toward equality. This idea of
freedom and equality gave great confidence and pride to these long oppressed
people.
Bibliography
Batty,
Peter The Divided Union, Tempus Publishing Limited, September 1999. Catton,
Bruce The Civil War, Houghton Mifflin Company, April 1985 Foner, Eric and
Mahoney, Olivia A House Divided, Norton, Ww, Louisania University Press, May
1991 McPherson, James M. The Negro?s Civil War: How Americans Felt and Acted
During the War for the Union., Ballantine Books, Inc., February 1989 Stokesbury,
James C. A Short History of the Civil War Morrow, William & Company, March,
1997 Wilson, Joseph T. The Black Phalanx: African-American Soliders in the War
of Independence and the Civil War Plenum Publishing Corp., April 1994